Payer Policy Pulse is Cotiviti’s monthly look at the news out of Washington and beyond that matters most to health plans, with concise summaries and key takeaways to help you anticipate change and strengthen payment accuracy, compliance, and quality performance.
In this edition, we cover new incentives, growing scrutiny of No Surprises, lawsuits over CMS Star Ratings, and more. Read on to learn what the latest developments could mean for your organization.
New incentives for earlier fraud reporting
The DOJ is encouraging earlier healthcare fraud reporting through two initiatives. Its Fraud Whistleblower Incentive Program (WHIP) offers eligible whistleblowers $10,000 to $30,000 for information leading to criminal charges in designated areas, including hospice and home health care fraud. A separate pilot encourages healthcare companies to self-disclose potential False Claims Act violations. Both reward earlier action to identify and address potential misconduct.
Key takeaways include:
- Earlier fraud detection is the clear priority. DOJ is creating incentives for both individuals and organizations to surface potential misconduct sooner.
- Several healthcare sectors are specifically in focus. Hospice, home health care, day care, and special services fraud are identified as priority areas under WHIP.
- Internal controls become even more important. Payers and healthcare organizations should have processes designed to identify, investigate, and escalate potential fraud before an external report forces the issue.
Growing scrutiny of No Surprises Act
The federal Independent Dispute Resolution (IDR) process is under growing scrutiny as dispute volumes far exceed expectations and qualifying payment amount (QPA) methodology faces court challenges. A new proposal, the Lower Premiums, Faster Payments Act, would eliminate the IDR process for services furnished on or after January 1, 2028, and make a recalculated QPA the out-of-network rate. Though still early-stage, it raises broader questions about how out-of-network payments should be set under the No Surprises Act.
Key takeaways include:
- IDR volume remains well beyond original expectations. The federal portal received more than 100 times the initially projected annual dispute volume in 2025.
- The QPA is increasingly central to the debate. Recent litigation and the new legislative proposal both challenge aspects of the framework used to determine out-of-network payments.
- Payers should watch both Congress and the courts. Even without near-term passage of the proposed legislation, changes to the IDR process or QPA methodology could affect payment calculations, workflows, and dispute operations.
Narrowing TCPA revocation
Effective November 25, 2026, narrower FCC rules replace the planned Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) “revoke-all” approach. Informational opt-outs may apply only to the communication category involved, and organizations may designate clearly disclosed revocation methods. Telemarketing opt-outs still apply across all future telemarketing from that caller. Health plans and vendors should review how they classify outreach and administer clear consent and opt-out processes.
Key takeaways include:
- Opt-outs may only apply to specific categories. Revocation may be limited to the category of informational communication the consumer opted out of.
- Classification matters. Plans should clearly distinguish informational outreach from advertising or telemarketing, particularly when communication could contain elements of both.
- Process and disclosure go together. Organizations using designated revocation methods will need to clearly disclose them and ensure their consent-management systems can apply opt-outs at the appropriate level.
New rules proposed for MA directory accuracy
CMS has proposed rules to implement the REAL Health Providers Act beginning in 2029, generally requiring Medicare Advantage plans to verify provider listings every 90 days, flag unverified listings, and analyze accuracy annually. Members relying on incorrect network listings would pay only in-network costs. The proposal links directory accuracy to claims, cost sharing, and documentation of the information members saw when seeking care.
Key takeaways include:
- Provider accuracy would require ongoing verification. Most listed providers would need to be verified at least every 90 days beginning in 2029.
- Directory errors could have direct claims consequences. Members relying on inaccurate network information would generally be protected from additional out-of-network cost sharing.
- Provider data will need to align across systems. Directory, credentialing, network, and claims data will increasingly need to reconcile, making inconsistent provider records an operational and payment accuracy issue as well as a compliance concern.
CMS sued for Star Ratings
CMS released its 2027 Medicare Advantage Star Ratings on October 8, setting the ratings used to determine 2028 quality bonus payments, but litigation is already raising questions about some results. As of November 12, 11 plans have sued, collectively alleging nearly $4 billion in 2028 losses. These cases build on earlier litigation over whether CMS properly adopted certain quality measures and had authority to use certain data. With the Clover decision under appeal, the fight is expanding into a broader test of how CMS establishes and applies its ratings methodology.
Key takeaways include:
- Financial stakes have increased sharply. Eleven plans challenging their 2027 ratings allege nearly $4 billion in combined losses for 2028.
- Disputes go beyond individual scores. At issue are questions about how CMS adopts measures and what data the agency is legally permitted to use in calculating Star Ratings.
- 2027 ratings may not be the final word for every plan. Payers using current Star Ratings to model 2028 quality bonus revenue should account for the possibility that ongoing litigation could affect individual ratings or the methodology used to calculate them.
Stay tuned for next month’s Payer Policy Pulse as we continue rounding up the news that matters most to health plans. Subscribe to our blog to make sure you don’t miss it.

